Last updated October 21, 2026 · ranked from 5,617 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 10 pizza places in and around Taylor, MI, led by Toarmina's Pizza, Karl's Place Pizza and Danny's Pizza & Subs. Together they have 5,617 Google reviews; Toarmina's Pizza has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.6. Every place on the list is in Taylor, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
Top picks at a glance
1Toarmina's PizzaA 24-inch pizza option, sweet sauce and flavored crusts give Toarmina's Pizza at 11054 Allen Rd in Taylor, MI a distinct place at the top of this list.
A 24-inch pizza option, sweet sauce and flavored crusts give Toarmina's Pizza at 11054 Allen Rd in Taylor, MI a distinct place at the top of this list. Its 4.6 Google rating across 853 reviews supports the number-one ranking, while one reviewer describes repeated satisfying visits after ordering pizza, cheese bread and salad for a family party. Others praise fresh ingredients and hot food. Counter service, dine-in, takeout and delivery offer several ways to order, with hours extending to 11 p.m. Thursday through Saturday.
24-inch pizza option
Sweet sauce
Flavored crusts
“The rib tips are out of this world nice and tender with a little bit of bones in them. The fries and coleslaw are also very good. I would order this again.”
At 9054 Telegraph Rd in Taylor, MI, this casual pizza spot offers takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery. Reviewers describe the food as hot, fresh, and flavorful, with one also praising courteous delivery drivers. Its price level of 1 adds to its appeal for a budget-minded order, while closing times of 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays make it useful for later dinners.
The Ecorse Road shop holds a 4.5-star Google rating from 490 reviews. One reviewer singles out the Danny's special without sauce, while another describes a friendly response to a request for air bubbles in the crust. Takeout, delivery and no-contact delivery offer several ways to order, and Friday and Saturday closing times extend to 1 a.m.
Late-night pizza
Takeout and delivery
4.5 Google stars
“I never knew that was a pizza place. Good pie, friendly staff watching the Luons game during pick up!”
Benito's Pizza holds a 4.4 Google rating across 518 reviews, listed on Google as pizza.
“Found out we were having a party and gave us some extra wedges 🥰🥰🥰 they are great and food is always on point. You will love the food here and the service even more. 👍🏻 we're here at least twice a month sometimes more depending on t…”
Little Caesars Pizza at 9633 Telegraph Rd in Taylor, MI is a carry-out chain serving pizza tossed from housemade dough, chicken wings, and…
“Thank you to the woman who prepared my order and offered me additional cookies for my children. Her communication on what items were "Hot n' Ready" and how long it may take for others items was appreciated. She suggested some lunch boxe…”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each pizza place is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Taylor category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which pizza places in Taylor, MI have the highest Google ratings?
The Cordial Shoppe leads these listings with 4.7 stars from 780 reviews, followed by Toarmina’s Pizza with 4.6 from 853 and Danny’s Pizza & Subs with 4.5 from 490. Karl’s Place Pizza and Benito’s Pizza each have 4.4 stars, from 616 and 518 reviews respectively.
Where can I get deep-dish or flavored-crust pizza in Taylor, MI?
PizzaPapalis at 14680 Pardee Rd serves deep-dish and thin-crust pizzas. Benito’s Pizza at 22267 Goddard Rd offers both styles along with flavored crusts. Toarmina’s Pizza at 11054 Allen Rd offers flavored crusts, sweet sauce and a 24-inch option.
Where can families sit down for pizza in Taylor, MI?
PizzaPapalis at 14680 Pardee Rd offers dine-in service, high chairs, a children’s menu and reservations. Mancino’s at 22765 Northline Rd also offers dine-in service, high chairs and a children’s menu, but does not accept reservations.
Which pizza places in Taylor, MI offer curbside pickup or a drive-through?
Toarmina’s Pizza at 11054 Allen Rd, Karl’s Place Pizza at 9054 Telegraph Rd and Mancino’s at 22765 Northline Rd offer curbside pickup. Little Caesars at 9633 Telegraph Rd has a drive-through. All four also offer delivery and takeout.